On Tue, Sep 19, 2017 at 11:16 AM, Gregg Levine <gregg.drwho8@gmail.com> wrote:

Wasn't the original project called "Athena", and wasn't it pursued by
one of the many Labs at MIT? 

Greg - not quite right, although I can see how I might look that way from the outside.   The Athena project was MIT's reaction to the CMU Andrew​ Project.  I'll not bring the somewhat humorous history but basic question asked was simple... assume CMU succeeded in building the proposed 3M 'SPICE' system for Andrew.   MIT wanted to know: How would you deploy it?  Athena set out to figure that out...

It's interesting the two pieces of Athena that actually still live are X and Kerberos where were developed as part of the Athena project.   I understand why Kerberos and much of that tech was needed if you were going to deploy hundreds of computers.   I don't remember the argument for writing X - i.e. why it was needed, you'd have to ask Dan Geer (I've forgotten).

FYI: In the case of Andrew, Mach and some of the AFS technology (and I've heard some suggest it helped to move IBM into the doing RIOS which eventually lead to Power/PC).

Clem